The Rise of Deed Fraud in New York: Safeguarding Your Real Estate Investments

Deed Fraud

New York has long been a prime destination for real estate investments, with its strong economy, diverse population, and world-class infrastructure. However, as the city’s real estate market has grown, so too has the prevalence of a dangerous and underreported crime: deed fraud. In recent years, New York has seen a significant increase in cases of deed fraud, with criminals using increasingly sophisticated methods to target unsuspecting property owners.

As a property owner or investor in New York, it is crucial to understand the risks posed by deed fraud and take steps to safeguard your investments. This article will provide an in-depth look at the phenomenon of deed fraud in New York, exploring how common it is, how it happens, and its consequences for property owners. We will also share real-life examples of deed fraud in New York, outline legal remedies and recourse for victims, and offer best practices for preventing deed theft.

Understanding deed fraud

Deed fraud, also known as deed theft, is a form of real estate fraud that involves the unauthorized transfer of a property’s title from the rightful owner to another person. This is typically accomplished through the use of forged signatures, fake identification documents, and other fraudulent means. Once the thief has successfully transferred the title, they may attempt to sell the property, take out loans against it, or even evict the rightful occupants.

Many people may wonder: is deed fraud real? The answer is an unfortunate and resounding yes. Deed fraud is a very real and growing problem in New York and other parts of the country, with criminals targeting properties of all types and values. The rise of online property records and the ease of accessing personal information have made it easier than ever for criminals to steal home titles.

How common is deed fraud in New York?

So, how common is deed fraud in New York? While it is difficult to determine the exact number of cases, it is clear that deed fraud is a significant and growing problem in the city. According to the New York City Department of Finance, there were more than 3,000 cases of deed fraud reported between 2014 and 2018. However, this number is likely just the tip of the iceberg, as many cases of deed fraud go unreported or undetected.

The problem is particularly acute in certain neighborhoods, such as Brooklyn and Queens, where rapidly rising property values have made real estate an attractive target for criminals. In these areas, cases of deed fraud have been reported at an alarming rate, with some estimates suggesting that as many as 1 in 5 properties may be at risk of deed fraud.

How it happens

Deed theft can occur in several ways, but the most common method involves the use of forged documents and false identities. Criminals may pose as property owners, real estate agents, or even government officials in order to fraudulently transfer a property’s title. They may also exploit vulnerabilities in the property registration system, such as the lack of a centralized database or the reliance on physical documents, to carry out their scheme.

In many cases, the property owner is completely unaware of the theft until it is too late. They may only discover the crime when they receive a notice of foreclosure, a demand for payment on a loan they never took out, or when they attempt to sell or refinance their property and find that the title is no longer in their name.

Consequences of deed theft for property owners

The consequences of deed fraud can be devastating for property owners, both financially and emotionally. Victims may find themselves facing foreclosure, eviction, or significant legal fees as they attempt to reclaim their property. They may also suffer damage to their credit rating and reputation, as well as the loss of their hard-earned investment.

Beyond the financial impact, deed fraud can also have serious emotional consequences for victims. The stress and uncertainty associated with losing one’s property can be overwhelming, particularly for elderly or vulnerable homeowners who may have limited resources to fight back against the fraud.

Real-life examples of deed fraud in New York

Sadly, there are many real-life examples of deed theft in New York that demonstrate the severity and complexity of this crime. In one high-profile case, a Brooklyn woman discovered that her family’s three-story brownstone had been fraudulently sold without her knowledge after the thief forged her signature on the deed. Despite having lived in the property for over 30 years, she was forced to fight a lengthy legal battle to reclaim her home, ultimately prevailing in court.

In another case, a Queens homeowner fell victim to deed theft when a group of criminals posing as government officials convinced her to sign over her property’s title in exchange for help with a supposed tax lien. The thieves then sold the property to an unsuspecting buyer, leaving the original homeowner with no recourse but to sue both the criminals and the new owner in a bid to recover her property.

How to safeguard your real estate investments from deed fraud

Given the serious consequences of deed fraud, it is essential for property owners and investors in New York to take steps to safeguard their real estate investments. One of the most effective ways to do this is by regularly monitoring your property records for any signs of unauthorized activity or changes. This can be done by signing up for a property monitoring service, which can alert you to any suspicious transactions or title changes.

Additionally, it is important to protect your personal information, as criminals may use this information to target your property. This includes regularly checking your credit report for any signs of identity theft, shredding sensitive documents, and being cautious when sharing your personal details online or over the phone.

Legal remedies and recourse for victims of deed fraud

If you discover that you have been the victim of deed fraud, it is crucial to act quickly to protect your rights and reclaim your property. The first step is to report the crime to your local law enforcement agency, as well as the New York State Attorney General’s Office and the New York City Department of Finance.

You should also consult with an experienced real estate attorney, who can help you navigate the complex legal process of recovering your property. This may involve filing a lawsuit against the perpetrators of the fraud, as well as any third parties who may have been involved in the transaction, such as buyers or lenders.

If your property has been fraudulently sold, you may also need to file a “lis pendens” with the county clerk’s office. This is a legal notice that alerts potential buyers and lenders that there is a dispute over the property’s ownership, which can help prevent further transactions until the matter is resolved.

Preventing deed theft: best practices for property owners

In order to prevent deed theft, property owners in New York should adopt a proactive approach to protecting their investments. This includes:

  1. Regularly monitoring your property records for any signs of unauthorized activity or changes. This can be done by signing up for a property monitoring service, which can alert you to any suspicious transactions or title changes.
  2. Protecting your personal information by regularly checking your credit report for any signs of identity theft, shredding sensitive documents, and being cautious when sharing your personal details online or over the phone.
  3. Ensuring that your property is properly registered with the county clerk’s office, and that you have up-to-date copies of all relevant documents, such as your deed and title.
  4. Being cautious when dealing with unsolicited offers or requests for personal information, particularly from individuals claiming to represent government agencies or real estate professionals.
  5. Educating yourself about the risks of deed fraud and staying informed about the latest scams and tactics used by criminals.

Conclusion: staying vigilant against deed fraud in New York

The rise of deed fraud in New York is a stark reminder of the importance of remaining vigilant and proactive in protecting your real estate investments. By understanding the risks posed by deed fraud and taking steps to safeguard your property, you can help ensure that your investment remains secure and your hard-earned assets are protected.

Remember to regularly monitor your property records, protect your personal information, and be cautious when dealing with unsolicited offers or requests for personal information. By staying informed and vigilant, you can help prevent deed theft and safeguard your valuable real estate investments in New York.

Schedule a Consultation

Gregory A. Byrnes

Gregory A. Byrnes
152 Madison Avenue
14th Floor
New York, NY 10016
(646) 448-5279


The Byrnes Law Office 2023. This website is considered attorney advertising. Information on this website has been prepared for general information. It is not meant to provide legal advice with respect to any specific matter and should not be acted upon without professional counsel.

Please do not include any confidential or sensitive information in a contact form, text message, or voicemail. The contact form sends information by non-encrypted email, which is not secure. Submitting a contact form, sending a text message, making a phone call, or leaving a voicemail does not create an attorney-client relationship.